My Bait Shop, LLC

Our specialty is curating and selling a wide variety of lures, including vintage, vintage, and collectible pieces. We are passionate about helping anglers find the perfect lure for their fishing adventures.

Whether you're a seasoned pro or a curious collector, our extensive selection of high-quality lures will exceed your expectations!

We offer an impressive array of new, used, and vintage fishing lures to suit every angler's needs. My Bait Shop offers a wide range of fishing lures, from classic crankbaits and wobbler lures to spinnerbaits, versatile jigs, and soft plastics. You'll find top brands like Heddon, Creek Chub, Rebel, Storm, Smithwick, and Rapala. Our catalog of products features the best lures on the market.

Vintage fishing lures come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and materials. Two common types of vintage fishing lures include:

• Wooden Fishing Lures: Many early fishing lures were made from wood, such as cedar, pine, or balsa. These lures were often hand-carved and painted with intricate designs. Wooden lures are highly collectible and can be quite valuable. Featuring an all wooden body, these lures have a classic style that are a must any collection.
• Metal Lures: Metal lures became popular in the early 1900s and were often made from materials like brass or tin. These lures were typically cast or stamped and were known for their durability and longevity.
• Plastic Lures:

Choosing the right lure can be a daunting task, but we're here to help. When choosing the right lure consider factors such as the target fish species, water conditions, and your preferred fishing technique.

At My Bait Shop, you'll find a team of dedicated anglers and outdoorsmen who live and breathe fishing. Our love for the sport is matched only by our commitment to preserving the rich history and tradition of lures.

Our knowledgeable staff is always ready to provide expert advice and recommendations tailored to your specific needs.

Vintage fishing lures have a unique charm that attracts collectors and anglers alike. These lures not only have historical significance but also showcase the craftsmanship and artistry of a bygone era.

Many vintage lures were hand-carved and hand-painted, making them true works of art. They evoke a sense of nostalgia and carry the stories of fishermen from years past. Owning a vintage fishing lure is like owning a piece of history. 

Yes, fishing with a lure that fish haven't seen before can be effective. This is because fish are often attracted to novel stimuli in their environment. When a new lure is introduced, it can trigger a predatory response in fish, as they may perceive it as potential prey.

Several factors contribute to the success of using new fishing lures:

• Curiosity: Fish may be curious about a new object in their environment and approach it to investigate. Especially when introducing "new species" like frog lures.
• Predatory instinct: A new lure with an attractive color, shape, or movement pattern can simulate prey and trigger a strike from predatory fish.
• Lack of negative associations: Fish that have never encountered a particular lure before haven't had the chance to develop a negative association with it, such as being hooked or spooked by it in the past.

Collecting Antique Fishing Lures

Collecting vintage fishing lures has become a popular hobby among fishing enthusiasts. These lures can be highly sought after and can fetch a significant price, especially if they are rare or in excellent condition.

Collecting vintage fishing lures can be a rewarding hobby and a way to connect with the rich history of fishing. When starting your collection, it's important to do your research and educate yourself about the different types of lures, their origins, and their value.

Are you wondering what fishing lures are worth the most money? We also have expert appraisers standing by to help you get the most out of your collection.

If you're lucky enough to own or acquire vintage fishing lures, proper care and maintenance are essential.

Here are a few tips to keep your vintage lures in excellent condition:

• Store them in a cool, dry place: Avoid storing your vintage fishing lures in areas with high humidity or temperature fluctuations. Moisture can cause wood to warp or metal to rust, so it's best to store them in a cool, dry place.
• Handle with care: Always handle your vintage lures gently, using clean hands or soft gloves to avoid damaging the finish or leaving oils and dirt on your skin.
• Clean gently: If your lures need cleaning, use a soft, dry cloth or soft-bristled brush to remove dirt and dust. Avoid using water or harsh chemicals, as they can damage the paint and finish.
• Monitor condition: Regularly check your lures for any signs of damage, such as cracks, chips, or peeling paint. Address any issues promptly to prevent further deterioration.
• Seek professional help: If your lures require extensive repairs or restoration, consider seeking the help of a professional specializing in vintage fishing tackle to ensure the best results and maintain the value of your collection in excellent condition.

Shopping for new, used, and vintage lures online has never been easier thanks to our user-friendly website. With just a few clicks, you can browse our extensive inventory of quality lures like Creek Chub Smithwick, and Rapala.

Learn about the history of a vintage lure that is worth a fortune! You may just have one in your tackle box right now.

We offer secure payment options and free domestic shipping for all orders of $25 or more, ensuring your lures arrive at your doorstep quickly and safely.

What sets our lure shop apart is our unwavering commitment to customer satisfaction.

From our carefully curated selection of lures to our exceptional customer service, we go above and beyond to ensure your shopping experience is second to none.

Our expert appraisal service will convert your tackle box into cold hard cash. We take pride in our expertise, reliability, and dedication to helping you find the perfect lures for your fishing adventures.

While modern fishing lures have their own appeal, there is a certain charm and nostalgia associated with vintage fishing lures.

These vintage pieces not only serve as collectibles but also hold historical significance in the world of fishing. Whether you're an avid angler or a collector, exploring our extensive inventory of vintage fishing lures offers an exciting glimpse into the past.